October
14th 2010
I’ve Got The Reformer-Michelle Rhee-Resigned-from-Her-Job-in-D.C. Blues

Posted under Innovation and Reform & PPC & Urban Schools

Sorry, no long post today. I’m sad, and reeling a bit. My edu-crush and reform hero Michelle Rhee has announced her resignation as chancellor of Washington, D.C., public schools. Guess I knew it was coming, but was probably in denial. The place to go for thoughtful reactions is School Reform News, where many respected education reformers weigh in (H/T Jay Greene’s blog) — including Robert Enlow, Virginia Walden Ford, Greg Forster, Matt Ladner and Lisa Snell. They offer an important reminder:

“Rhee was overhyped in the sense that reformers need to put broad systemic reforms in place, like the DC charter law, in addition to strong leaders,” Ladner said. “Rhee lasted approximately the average tenure for an urban superintendent. Leaders come and go, but the struggle for reform goes on.”

“Rhee was not overhyped,” said Forster. “What was overhyped was the whole heroic reformer model that says the system can work as long as we put the right people in charge of it.”

“Now we know that if you ever really do get the right people in charge of it, the unions just pull out all the stops to destroy those people,” he said. “We need to change the system in a way that breaks the unions, and only universal school choice can do that.”

Snell agreed, calling Rhee’s tenure “a cautionary tale” against relying to heavily on one strong individual rather than legal and structural reforms.

“Charter schools are a case in point,” Snell explained. “While there are many charismatic charter school leaders, these schools still only thrive in states where the laws make it easier to open a charter school.”

Hopefully reflecting on their insights will have me feeling better by tomorrow.

3 Comments »

3 Responses to “I’ve Got The Reformer-Michelle Rhee-Resigned-from-Her-Job-in-D.C. Blues”

  1. Ed is Watching » As Waiting for Superman Opens Today in Colorado, Listen to an Exclusive Interview with Director Davis Guggenheim on 15 Oct 2010 at 9:20 am #

    [...] going to see the movie today. Do you think they invited me? No. Not even to cheer me up from the “Reformer-Michelle Rhee-Resigned-from-Her-Job-in-D.C.” Blues. So maybe if they read this, they’ll feel guilty and invite me along. At least I hope [...]

  2. Ed is Watching » Best Wishes to Michelle Rhee & Indiana Leaders, Even If Selfish of Me to Say So on 13 Dec 2010 at 1:11 pm #

    [...] was about two months ago you all had to help me fight back the tears after the news that Michelle Rhee was forced out of her job as D.C. schools chancellor. But [...]

  3. Ed is Watching » Michelle Rhee Hits a Denver Home Run While Her Critics Swing and Miss Again on 27 May 2011 at 11:59 am #

    [...] when you’re forever 5 years old, time flies. I can hardly believe it was last October that I cried to learn my edu-crush Michelle Rhee was leaving her important superintendent job at D.C. Public [...]

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply